IHC Scoring (ASCO/CAP 2018)
| Score | Pattern | Threshold | Next step |
| 0 |
No staining, OR incomplete faint/barely perceptible staining |
Any % of cells |
HER2-negative. No reflex ISH. |
| 1+ |
Incomplete membrane staining — faint/barely perceptible |
>10% invasive cells |
HER2-low — eligible for T-DXd. No reflex ISH required. |
| 2+ |
Weak–moderate complete membrane staining, OR intense complete staining |
>10% invasive cells (weak–mod), OR ≤10% (intense) |
Equivocal → reflex ISH required |
| 3+ |
Intense complete circumferential membrane staining |
>10% invasive cells |
HER2-positive — anti-HER2 therapy eligible |
⚠ HER2-ultralow (2024): IHC >0 but <1+ (incomplete staining in ≤10% of cells). DESTINY-Breast06 showed T-DXd benefit — report and document carefully; do not call these IHC 0.
HER2-Low — The New Category
Definition: IHC 1+ OR IHC 2+ / ISH-negative (HER2/CEP17 <2.0 AND avg HER2 <4.0).
~55–60% of HR+ and ~35–40% of TNBC cases qualify as HER2-low. Re-testing of archival tissue or metastatic biopsy may be warranted given therapeutic implications.
KEY TRIAL
DESTINY-Breast04
T-DXd vs physician's choice chemo in HER2-low mBC. PFS 9.9 vs 5.1 mo (HR+ cohort); OS benefit confirmed.
KEY TRIAL
DESTINY-Breast06
T-DXd in HER2-low AND HER2-ultralow HR+ mBC. Extends benefit to ultralow category; supports meticulous IHC reporting.
ISH Algorithm — 5 Groups (ASCO/CAP 2018, Dual-Probe)
| Group | HER2/CEP17 ratio | Avg HER2/cell | Result |
| 1 | ≥2.0 | ≥4.0 | Positive |
| 2 | ≥2.0 | <4.0 | Positive (if IHC 3+) or Negative (if IHC 0/1+/2+) — requires IHC correlation |
| 3 | <2.0 | ≥6.0 | Positive (if IHC 3+/2+) or Negative (if IHC 0/1+) |
| 4 | <2.0 | ≥4.0 and <6.0 | Negative (unless IHC 3+) |
| 5 | <2.0 | <4.0 | Negative |
⚠ For groups 2–4: ISH result must be interpreted in conjunction with concurrent IHC result. If discordant, retest or use alternative ISH probe.
Treatment by HER2 Category
HER2-POSITIVE (IHC 3+ or 2+/ISH+)
Trastuzumab (Herceptin)PertuzumabT-DM1 (ado-trastuzumab emtansine)T-DXd (trastuzumab deruxtecan)Tucatinib + capecitabine + trastuzumabNeratinibLapatinib
HER2-LOW (IHC 1+ or 2+/ISH–)
T-DXd (trastuzumab deruxtecan) — DESTINY-Breast04
HR+/HER2-low: T-DXd after ≥1 line of endocrine therapy. TNBC/HER2-low: after ≥1 line of chemo.
HER2-ULTRALOW (>0 but <1+)
T-DXd showed PFS benefit in DESTINY-Breast06 (HR+ cohort). FDA approval pending — document carefully, do not score as 0.
Testing Workflow
1
Initial IHC on core biopsy or excision (invasive component only). Use validated antibody (4B5, SP3, CB11, or equivalent).
2
If 3+ → HER2-positive. Report and proceed to treatment planning. No ISH needed.
3
If 2+ → Equivocal. Reflex ISH on same block (dual-probe preferred). Apply 5-group algorithm.
4
If 1+ → HER2-low. No ISH required. Report as 1+ and flag HER2-low eligibility.
5
If 0 with ANY staining in ≤10% cells → Document HER2-ultralow carefully. Do not report as "0" without noting staining pattern.
6
Metastatic disease: Retest on metastatic biopsy when feasible. HER2 status can evolve (upregulation or loss). Prior anti-HER2 therapy does not preclude HER2-low re-classification.
Common Pitfalls & Reporting Tips
Avoid "HER2-negative" as sole report — distinguish 0, 1+ (HER2-low), and 2+/ISH– (HER2-low) explicitly. Each category has distinct therapeutic meaning.
Basolateral/lateral staining (not circumferential) should not be scored as 3+; seen in normal glands and may indicate non-specific staining.
Chromosome 17 polysomy: HER2/CEP17 ratio may be falsely low. Consider HER2 copy number and consult molecular correlates.
Post-neoadjuvant specimens: Residual disease HER2 status guides adjuvant T-DM1 (KATHERINE trial). Re-test residual invasive tumor after NAC.
Intratumoral heterogeneity: Report the % of cells with each staining pattern. For borderline 2+ vs 3+, err toward 2+ and reflex ISH. Neoadjuvant therapy may alter HER2 expression.
References: Wolff AC et al. J Clin Oncol 2018 (ASCO/CAP HER2 guidelines) · Modi S et al. NEJM 2022 (DESTINY-Breast04) · Curigliano G et al. NEJM 2024 (DESTINY-Breast06). Content is educational — always apply institutional protocols and current FDA labelling.